First NewsFirst TVSubscriptions

Showbiz News

Friday, 18 November 2011




Is Amelia Lily's X Factor return fair?

Was it fair of X factor to let Amelia Lily return? 

After Frankie Cocozza was kicked off The X Factor, Amelia Lily returned to the competition after a public vote.

The teen was voted off the show after the first live show by her mentor Kelly Rowland.

This week she received 48% of the votes, beating 2Shoes, James Michael and Jonjo Kerr. 

However, X Factor reject Kitty Brucknell has said that it was 'unfair' that she was allowed to return, and wondered if this was the plan all along. She said: "It is a little bit weird, all of us felt very two sided about it.

"We kind of really worked hard for six weeks and suddenly she's just come back in the competition.

"You never know, that could have been their intention all along."

Do you think it was fair of the X factor judges to let Amelia Lily return? Leave a comment below to let us know…

 





What do you think? Leave a comment below to let us know!

Please note: All comments are moderated before they go live.
Offensive comments will not be published.


Did you like this? Why not give it a Thumbs Up!

10 Thumbs Up!

Give this article a Thumbs Up! by logging in
to your account or registering here.


16 Comments


You must be logged in to your account to add a comment about this article.


  • musicluva (Age 12) wrote on Friday, 18 November 2011 @ 16:36

    I think it was not fair. Because she left at the first day if the finals, it shouldnt be her. I think it should have been the person who last got voted out of the show. Amelia has a good voice it is just not fair.

  • emha (Age 8) wrote on Friday, 18 November 2011 @ 19:40

    I think it is fair

  • jlsfan3 (Age 13) wrote on Saturday, 19 November 2011 @ 15:53

    yes and no! no because it should have been the last one that was voted out but yes because out of the 4 chosen the public liked her the most.

  • charan (Age 13) wrote on Tuesday, 22 November 2011 @ 19:10

    It is fair-she's AMAZING!

  • digglered1 (Age 13) wrote on Tuesday, 22 November 2011 @ 19:22

    Yes! The public voted her back in.

  • Ellie-mo (Age 13) wrote on Tuesday, 22 November 2011 @ 22:05

    No! I dont think it was fair at all! I mean, all the other contestants have been in the competition for way longer and have had to work harder for it, then all of a sudden, Amelia just comes in with only, like, 2 weeks on the show!! I REALLY DON'T THINK IT WAS FAIR!!!!!

  • redhorse10 (Age 14) wrote on Thursday, 24 November 2011 @ 16:16

    I agree with Musiclova! It was unfair because she obviously isn't good enough, that is why Kelly kicked her off in the first round of the live shows! All of the others had to work hard for longer and then suddenly she just comes back. I think it COULD be fixed as Kitty said. Johnny should have come back because he was the last to get voted off and was way better than A-L anyway! Amelia-Lily to leave!

  • peace111 (Age 12) wrote on Thursday, 24 November 2011 @ 18:43

    as much as i like herrr its not fairrrr the risk shouldve come innnnn xx cant believe they were voteddd outt xx :( if it wasnt forr janet and little mix i wouldnt be watchinggg sooooo.......;)

  • redhorse10 (Age 14) wrote on Friday, 25 November 2011 @ 18:34

    No, the Risk should not have because they did no work either! Janet's not good - she's really boring and predictable. LM are ok. :)

  • shoeless27 (Age 10) wrote on Friday, 25 November 2011 @ 20:13

    Yes + NO WAY! Yes, because she was voted on, so YOU decided {kind of}, and No, because she was off early. But, MORE YES because if you had another shot at it, you would want to win it. So really, it's FAIR FAIR FAIR . :):):):):):) {If you think this statement is unfair, don't blame me I don't watch it. EVER.

  • IA555 (Age 10) wrote on Saturday, 26 November 2011 @ 15:02

    yeah and no! i want sophie habibis to come back but i like amelia lily too

  • peace111 (Age 12) wrote on Sunday, 27 November 2011 @ 22:05

    yh but on friday kelly lettt it splill that she was soo happy for amelia being bck!!! then it was announced on sunday or saturday so.......:s

  • fizzy21 (Age 11) wrote on Monday, 28 November 2011 @ 18:10

    Hmmm...

  • laurcool (Age 12) wrote on Tuesday, 29 November 2011 @ 18:24

    It's not fair as everyone else has said. Imagine if she won!

  • AquaPuppy (Age 11) wrote on Wednesday, 30 November 2011 @ 19:39

    It IS fair, in my opinion! I think that Amelia did not deserve to go on the first night, it should have been Sophie! She is really talented and has a lot of star quality and potential, and I could see her selling records!

  • tattyted (Age 10) wrote on Saturday, 10 December 2011 @ 17:56

    It is fair but all my friends and me wanted Johnny back. he was really funny. Amelia is good and she got voted in by the public